I don’t understand this. I cant even name a single community native to the instance I use. I picked one that hadn’t defederated from anyone, and I block communities as needed. Also subscriptions are a thing.
How do you find out if they defederated from instances?
Built by yours truly
Do you have any plans to add support for showing when a Lemmy or Kbin instance has defederated from Mastodon, Pleroma, Peertube, Soapbox, Misskey, etc. instances? That seems to be the only flaw when tracking Lemmy deferations.
Adding support for Kbin is definitely a priority. When I built that tool Kbin didn’t have public defederation lists (yet?) though a pull request to implement that was in the works. Idk what’s the status on that is, but as soon as it’s merged I’ll also add Kbin.
For any other software it’s a little trickier. Unless there some way to check for this through ActivityPub of which I’m not aware, I have to go through software specific steps to scan those instances. This means that for Lemmy I go through an API that only exists on Lemmy, when I’ll add Kbin I’ll have to write some new code that will only write for Kbin and so on. This isn’t really sustainable for EVERY fedi platform out there, I won’t do that.
Moreover, as you saw there was a progress bar. That’s your computer querying each one of those 300 instances looking for their defed lists. The more software I add, the more instances you as a user have to query, the longer it takes to run a search. All in all I don’t think I’ll add support for any other software aside from Kbin and possibly Mastodon.
Nice! I’m bookmarking this.
Nice, this is useful
Incredibly useful tool.
will add to home screen
Great. This is so useful.
Replace it with your instance domain.
I found a link to a list of who is defederated from whom on a “fediverse for beginners” post. I will see if I can find it again if you need, but it looks like some other commenters already got you covered.
If you find out please let me know too. Thanks
I built a tool for that
Actually lemmy.one defederates from lemmygrad.ml
Which is kinda weird because they allow everything else but I guess it’s okay.
Ah. Interesting. I sort of forgot about lemmygrad altogether. Guess that explains why.
“Decline in overall quality” is a subjective metric, though. Does defederation reduce participation? Certainly.
But ya know, there’s a reason people defederate certain instances – usually because those instances have attracted people who are disruptive to discussion on other instances.
It’s really been no problem at all for me to keep a foot in lemmy.world, kbin.social, lemmy.ml, and beehaw.org. And a few other instances that appeal to more niche audiences.
And if I really feel like discussion on an instance is offering something and I’m missing out, I can always get an account there.
Not that I’m arguing against better moderation tools, of course. By all means, lemmy devs should prioritize those as soon as scaling/stability issues are dealt with.
Yep, when I get sick of the rhetoric here I just jump over to hexbear where they make fun of the people I tend to disagree with frequently here. . I think the best moderation tools would be to attempt to decentralize it so the petty tyrants the role seems to attract can’t abuse their authority to censor opinions they don’t agree with regardless of whether or not the content actually conflicts with the rules.
Sounds like you’d like it better over there full-time.
Or… just let people live with their multiple personalities. It’s not like people didn’t have alt accounts on Reddit specifically so they could talk about stuff in a way that wouldn’t reflect on their primary account.
As long as people behave appropriately on an instance, it’s nobody else’s business what they do on other instances with different accounts.
I never said they couldn’t? Just making an observation about what their declared preferences suggest.
Also, they’re the ones advocating for all-inclusive access. Personally I think everything works well enough as-is. If a user gets annoyed or tired of an instance, they can quite easily hop to another. No need to restrict the abilities of admins just because wants to browse chapotraphouse on their main.
you’d like it better over there full-time
The passive-aggressive version of “don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out”.
And? That’s still not saying anything about people with more than one account.
Meh happy to block another hb going by another name. Ez win
He would have never guessed that I was at lemmy.world first. lol, probably would have broke his brainwashing to acknowledge another user as a human being he would have to consider the opinion of. Just pretend everyone’s out to get you for reasons other people made up for you. Back to sleep little one.
What chain of logic lead you to that conclusion?
Turns out people that want to cause trouble will just make new accounts on your instance if you defederate from theirs.
No need to waste energy making a real point then, lol people here just make shit up and then posture as if it makes them right somehow. Look, I’m doing it! No need to actually have any basis for my opinion that no one asked for! :D damn Armok: God of Blood HOW DID I NOT THINK OF THIS BEFORE!?! Lol wait, accidentally asked you to think critically. lol. My bad, carry on.
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
I’m an example of a filthy casual reddit user who is really struggling to find value in lemmy. Finding an instance where local is of value is difficult, world may as well be “everything”, and “everything” is a nightmarish hodgepodge of memes for teenagers, furry porn, really niche technical discussions, and star Trek memes. I never stay in the app longer than a few minutes and I feel like I spend more time blocking weird porn communities than I do reading interesting articles.
The other major issue is having to sort through the exact same article 60 times because people cross post not only to local communities but then also the same communities are duplicated on every instance. I’m probably going to abandon this soon unless I can find some kind of curated community list to subscribe to or something.
I don’t really get all the “‘all’ is bad” discussion. Isn’t that what the “subscribed” feed is for? Just sub to the communities that interest you and browse from there. Just like it was back on Reddit.
The big difference is 1. Finding communities is not easy. Can you name every one of your interests off the top of your head? 2. Just punching in communities from reddit 1 for 1 doesn’t work. 3. Content and user base. There are no discussions for my favorite podcasts here and if there are where do I find them.
It took me a decade to build out a decent sub list on Reddit and I still stumble upon new interests now and again. I don’t know how to “stumble upon” decent communities on Lemmy and I’m sick of wading through cartoon horse cocks.
If you have a decent list from Reddit you can use https://sub.rehab to map Reddit to Lemmy / Kbin
If you just want to look for communities you can use https://browse.feddit.de
Takes some time to get everything set up but I honestly prefer having only stuff that interests me in my feed + no porn randomly popping up
Appreciate the leads here!
Also check out https://lemmyverse.net
They still call it squabbles on that site lol
Yeah I think that respondent is being defensive and really doesn’t get the point.
Discovery sucks. Its really bad and its hurting the ability of lemmy to be a viable alternative.
Option number 2 worked pretty well for me, porting from Reddit. Not perfect but then neither was reddit.
One thing I don’t like about the approach of blocking things is that the frontpage of reddit still allowed some level of discovery. If something in a niche community got hot enough it would break into my feed even though I didn’t subscribe to that community. It was a cool way to expand my content on an occasional basis.
If I’m going to only view my subscribed list on lemmy then I have to also manually go out and intentionally discover new communities. That’s hard, because some of my favorite small reddit communities were ones I never would have thought to search for.
That got me very confused as I never had that happening on my Reddit feed. I had to go back to Reddit to notice that I actually had that setting disabled.
Anyway, I don’t think something like that would really work on Lemmy. Reddit has his algorithm that devours your privacy, chews on your data and spits out results that may or may not interests you. Lemmy is much more simple than that. IIRC it’s “algorithm” is little more than a logarithmic curve and the (very based) devs are committed to user privacy, so your data will never get analyzed, not even to sugar coat your feed. For me it’s a feature, though I get that not everyone might feel that way.
the (very based) devs are committed to user privacy, so your data will never get analyzed
All credit to the devs, but Lemmy isn’t great on privacy. Your votes are technically public, and there is no way to guarantee what you delete or edit is actually deleted and edited. You’re right the data is not used to customize your feed, but not because it’s private. It isn’t.
You are right. I don’t mind the upvotes being public, I do mind the deletion thing (although it’s an inherent flaw of federation, hard to get around it) but both are points against it having good privacy.
I guess what I meant is that the platform makes no attempt at linking your online persona to anything else. It doesn’t even collect IP adresses and has very poor logging - btw this is actually a liability with the ongoing CSAM issue.
That got me very confused as I never had that happening on my Reddit feed.
Same for me, and I never had trouble finding new content. Discovering subreddits (and communities) through word-of-mouth worked perfectly fine.
Also, unlike Reddit, Lemmy has a community browser.
I mean, I use my LW account for local and lemm.ee for all (because it can see more posts). They are just… different, although I am getting pretty annoyed at the mass of r/politics level politcal discourse on the LW local feed.
What do you mean “it can see more posts”? I thought the point of world was that it was the general everything respiratory.
lemmy.world has been defederated and has defederated some pretty large instances. On the othe hand lemm.ee is probably the instance with one of the most open fed lists
DUMB. Just another reason for the average user to not bother with the platform IMHO. I can’t be arsed to figure out who is censoring or who isn’t I just want it to work.
You can view all blocked instances by viewing the /instances page and scrolling to the bottom.
For lemmy.world you just check https://lemmy.world/instances
Off the top of my head, LW accounts can’t see posts from beehaw, hexbear, or piracy communities on db0 due to defed/blocks.
Whaaaaaat. See this is the shit I’m talking about. Stupid I have to watch out for these kinds of pitfalls that I only know about because somebody happens to tell me.
I only know about because somebody happens to tell me
I agree on that point, I have built a site to check for that https://defed.xyz but you still have to query each instance manually. It’s just the way Lemmy works, some research is required when creating your account. I could write you a whole spielt on what criteria you should look at but the short answer is that if you want something big that “just works” lemm.ee might be the place for you.
Appreciate the feedback, I definitely want it to “just work”.
I browse all and block communties I have no interest in.
Bye bye Star Trek memes and may the force live long and prosper.
Did you hide all NSFW and still get that problem?
That seems to be the growing consensus on some of the biggest instances. Hopefully they start prioritizing that, or some other nice dev who knows Rust will. Maybe I need to start brushing up on it lol.
I didn’t see really any questions relating to mod tools or moderation outside of the one that was talking about the join-lemmy lists. Is that what you are referring to or do you mean the lack of mod tool discussion on that AMA?
A couple of beehaw admin had questions about the status of moderation tooling and the Lemmy Devs were like “not an emphasis”
I kind of feel like that may be a major strategic mistake.
It won’t be long before any given instance is overrun with alt right or other disruptive sorts if there aren’t good tools to help moderators/admins.
One of beehaw’s admins’ feature requests is for more granular instance controls such as blocking (defederating) at the community level.
To be fair, I think at the time, Lemmy had major performance issues. I can see how sorting that out is a big priority as well.
Why did two people downvote this? That’s exactly what happened. The devs stated they didn’t care much for mod tools at the moment and also stated they wouldn’t remove exploding heads from join-lemmy in another thread in the AMA, which is a whole other level of wtf.
The reality of it is that the platform wasn’t well thought out. The primary motivation was to copy Reddit functionally from a users perspective. That moderation tooling wasn’t even much of an afterthought is telling considering the language choice.
Just waiting on someone to create Reddit in forum form so long discussions over weeks/months/years on any type of subject can happen…
Think those are just called forums?
Some things like federated identities, or even federated content would go a long way into making forums a thing again.
I still think lemmy could use a “community type” enum where you can say what kind of discussion you want there.
Yes, what I mean is instead of having separate forums for everything, a Reddit/Lemmy type platform where people can create their own community to start threads. So if I wanted I could create a tractor community with sub communities for different brands and in there would be a single discussion to discuss a specific model, but my credentials would also allow me to go on the cooking community, in the baking sub community to take part in a discussion on strawberry shortcakes that’s been going on for months…
Reddit type “forums” just lead to the same questions/content being posted again and again and if you know a lot about a subject and just happen to miss the one time someone asks a question about it then that discussion is lost to time.
Ah, I see what you mean. I feel like that adds a lot of moderation overhead though because it needs people there to stop nefarious grave-digging.
Instead of resurrecting old posts, on Reddit/Lemmy you have people asking the same question again and again and again… On the cars subreddit you have the same “most interesting 5k$ car for sale around where you live” post getting created every few weeks, on a bulletin board you would have a single thread and people would just post new stuff when it comes out, the thread would come back to the top of the community’s front page and those interested would go check the newer reply…
I’m honestly surprised how many people that reply to me don’t seem to have experienced bulletin boards considering they’re still the place that “experts” hang on for most things (vs Reddit that is a better fit for enthusiasts that don’t want very technical info)…
Cheers, still use forums for very granular info. I think it’s more of a scale issue. If you put the volume of users on these niche forums as are on reddit/lemmy, I think the multi-post nonsense would ensue. I remember having to tell a lot of people to use the search in forums. Sounds similar.
Kind of like if there was a Lemmy Star Trek server and it hosted a bunch of communities with different topics that are all related to Star Trek?
The architecture is in place to do what you’re talking about. Just needs the right people to adopt the approach over time.
deleted by creator
Yes and no, the bulletin board system leads to more in depth discussions than anything you’ll ever get on the Reddit system of discussions that don’t get bumped…
So what I’m talking about is a decentralized bulletin board system with the federation system in place, so you can sign up to the Star Trek bulletin board but use the same log in to post on the Home Renovations bulletin board…
Basically, fix the biggest issue with forums, i.e. having to create an account for every single topic that interests you.
That’s just a function of how the host server sorts posts.
I am fairly sure that functionality could be implemented without the need to even fork the version.You can go to your user setting and select new comments and do this now.
It still doesn’t work like bulletin boards where all users would see discussions get bumped and replies were linear. It only works if the sorting mechanism is the same for everyone and the discussion is ongoing. I could point you to discussions that are still active more than ten years after they started, where all the knowledge available on a subject is available…
Here’s an example: https://www.advrider.com/f/threads/klr650-only-thread.742912/
Over 42 000 replies over 12 years on that specific model of motorcycle, that’s simply impossible on a platform that doesn’t work like bulletin boards do.
Bulletin boards is like having people sitting at a table and discussing a specific subject. Reddit/Lemmy is like an event with everyone scattered around the place with groups each having separate conversations, it might be a Star Trek convention, but you can’t follow every conversations so the same thing keeps getting repeated again and again by different people because they don’t realize someone already said the same thing.
There’s a reason specialists still hang on forums and enthusiasts hang on Reddit…
Edit: The Lemmy devs even started developing my idea, but development stopped when the Exodus happened…
I miss forums so much. A federated backend for forums would be nice. I’m so tired of having these giant communities of angry strangers if I want to talk about anything
deleted by creator
Ironically that’s also lemmy https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmyBB
😱
Edit: And both instances don’t work 🤣
Oh yeah i forgot to mention it hasn’t been maintained since the huge influx of users
In theory, but I used to hate when people would get mad at threads getting brought back from the dead. If the person has a question relevant to the topic, why start a new thread?
Not as if that was solved by instead having people tell OP to research the answer one of the many (now dead) discussions where the same question was asked!
Exactly, some people would complain about bringing back zombie threads, while others whine that people didn’t use the search feature to find existing threads on the topic. You can’t win either way with forum gatekeepers.
That’s a culture-thing. I’m a member of two forums that are still pretty active. One views dead thread revivals as amusing, the other almost literally has a celebration in-thread when it happens as all the members with older posts in it come piling in. Heck, the second forum has a thread so active that people literally ask for, and get, recaps for the last X amount of time for it.
???
Why do people not seem to know that the subscribed feed exists?
They do.
But, if they used subscribed, they wouldn’t be able to fuss about all of the stuff they don’t want to see.
Instead, they just want to look at everything. and then block instances (not communities) showing things they don’t want to see.
I just wish I could block porn instances. I like porn as much as the next guy, but I don’t want it offered to me every time I browse Lemmy.
There is a current PR, which I think has been merged. That being said, next release will likely contain that functionality.
I keep hearing this complaint. At the same time I have literally never seen porn in my Lemmy feed. This is absolutely mysterious to me.
Maybe you’ve blocked NSFW when registering.
You probably have chosen to hide nsfw content.
I don’t necessarily want to hide all nsfw stuff. But if things continue like this, I might have to do so.
I won’t let a little thing like jerkin’ it to furry porn get in the way of my jerkin’ off to bondage porn.
The Connect app has implemented instance blocking, as well as blocking a community without having to visit it.
Thanks! I’ll check it out.
there are more than one app that allows you to block instances.
for example sync can filter*:
- words
- communities
- users
- instances
*filter is a sync functionality, for communities and user use block if you want to have them blocked outside sync
See the problem is that if they use subscribed, other people might look at things they don’t think other people should look at!
Because they want to find new stuff maybe?
Well half the things I’ve tried to sub to say ‘pending’ then never get added to my feeds so that needs to be fixed. I don’t think it’s a jerboa issue because I’ve had it on desktop too.
I don’t really know what’s happening there, am I waiting for permission to subscribe? Waiting for it to sync between local and remote instances? For my local client to communicate with the instance I’m on or the the community is on?
Either way there should be an intermediary step where is stored locally soi I can find it again
if you hit refresh while it is in the pending state, does it go to subscribed?
i’ve seen it on the website, but it is just a graphical glitch. you did indeed subscribe to the community, just the front end never gets updated to reflect it.
but this might be outdated, it has been a long time since i last used the website.
i use sync btw, and here it works. you hit subscribe and the ui reflects the change
No it never changes and the community never gets added to my list, it’s only when trying to sub to communities from other instances as far as I can tell
that’s not supposed to happen, please do report it to the instance admin
Can’t argue with that, hopefully they improve before the biggest instances decide to partly close on themselves
Too late for that!
Is it?
The top five instances aren’t even all federated together…
But I like the all feed
Me too but we are also on lemmy.world which is well moderated (and I think also has the resources to do so)
I am not haha
Oh my bad. I’m using it on the phone and its not showing which instance users belong apparantly … :(
But then you are on another well moderated instance
The biggest thing killing Lemmy for me is needing a seperate account on every single instance if I want to participate in anything on an instance.
I thought this wasn’t how it was supposed to work.
I saw this post on another instance and tried to reply this exact message but got an error saying I couldn’t.
Using Liftoff if it matters.
That’s odd, you shouldn’t need another account. I’ve even made posts from this account to another instance
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Hello! Dev of Summit for Lemmy here. Summit actually supports switching accounts while keeping the same post open. Of course due to defederation it is not always possible to open a post on another account but it tries it’s best.
You definitely don’t need accounts for every instances (as long as you’re not defederated). That sounds like an app bug or something.
On Liftoff you need to “open using another instance” and then choose the instance your account is on
I just subscribe to whatever content I want to see. Wish my feed defaulted to subscribed instead of all because I hate lemm.ee.
Also it can be really hard finding small communities from a different instance, a lot don’t show up or aren’t fully synced so some of the posts don’t show.
Hopefully this is going to be fixed but I think it’s limiting the growth of more niche communities.
That’s what the subscribed feed is for.
But you NEED a functioning feed to discover new stuff ACROSS the threadiverse. How else will you be able to find other communities?
Search, people link to them, looking at community lists on interesting instances, etc. Honestly browsing by all as it currently exists is one of the worst ways to find new communities. Maybe that could be improved but that’s where it stands today.
This, and via crossposting. I discovered a couple of interesting communities because someone cross-posted stuff I was interested in to those communities. Likewise, I try to cross-post my own post to some popular communities, and niche communities to give them more visibility.
Why are people wondering that lemmy.world gets bigger and bigger if everone is told to stay on their local/subscribed feed
I respectfully disagree. On our LW Android comm, the discussion quality is generally pretty good, except when a post get on the front page, then the quality just drops like a rock.
Smaller (but not too small) crowd usually lead to higher quality discussions, that’s true on reddit(default subreddits are pretty much all terrible) , and that’s true here as well. (the turning point for quality decline reddit is at about 20K subscribers). So, I don’t think the "instance protectionism lead to lower discussion quality is true at all.)
Also, I think the mod tools here is basic but perfectly adequate. You can check our community’s mod log to see how much post removal/bans we actually had to do, and it’s not a lot. Also not to brag, but I think our weekly discussions are some of the best threads on Lemmy right now.
It’s not hard, I just tell our comm’s users that I expect them to act like adults, and most of them act like adults, and we just remove the post of the few who refuses to do so (they are like in the single digits over the last months) and our admins usually handle the trolls that requires site wide bans in literal minutes here.
I don’t use bots to mod and still do not see the need for it, because it turns out that if you cultivate a good culture in your community, moderation is pretty easy. That’s just my experience here though.
Ironic you used lemm.ee account to talk about LW :)
Well, LW still shows up to my all feed, so I just comment on posts if it comes up.
Yeah thats the problem - too many comments. /s
Instances shouldn’t be first class citizens, they should be more invisible to the users. The fediverse should be more like a cloud. Communities should be the primary focus, and only allow Instances to control how many users/communities they are the primary/secondary source for.
Disagree. Indeed, I couldn’t disagree more strongly.
Instances are not just abstract server nodes in some overly wasteful recreation of some other website. This is the world wide social web as it should have been.
You may as well argue that websites should be indistinguishable from each other.
This isn’t Reddit. Full stop. And it’s not a drop-in Reddit replacement, either. It’s not “Reddit, but different”. It’s a whole new paradigm in forums and content aggregation. It’s very different from centralized social media, and we need to stop dancing around or trying to hide that fact.
It will never get to reach its potential if we decide it needs to be nothing more than a simulacra of what came before it.
This is the world wide social web as it should have been.
This is my stance too - we took a wrong turn letting initially utopian tech companies create vast eyeball-farming dystopias when the natural progression from forums and blogs is breaking them out of their silos (not building bigger ones) and letting them talk to each other.
This isn’t Reddit. Full stop. And it’s not a drop-in Reddit replacement, either. It’s not “Reddit, but different”. It’s a whole new paradigm in forums and content aggregation. It’s very different from centralized social media, and we need to stop dancing around or trying to hide that fact.
Indeed. It’s early days still and the Reddit diaspora has shaped the initial growth but, as it spreads beyond that, it will expand and mutate. Already kbin have a kind of forum/microblogging thing going and it will be interesting to see how things evolve from here. With better moderation tools, I could see people skipping setting up their own forum and blog and just spinning up an instance instead - there are too many advantages to not do it. That’ll drag in a more diverse group of people with different needs and requirements that will push development in new directions. I, for one, can’t wait to see where this all goes.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but there already exists a proposal to make communities work more like a cloud.
It’s just a matter of time before Lemmy and Kbin implement this.
It’s a proposal, not a certainty. There’ve been a bunch of proposals for ways to allow people to aggregate communities from multiple instances together and it’ll be a handy tool to have, but it doesn’t change the fundamental properties of the Fediverse. It just makes it more convenient to use it in various different ways.
To use a somewhat stretched analogy. Instances should be like bitcoin miners, I don’t need to know much about them individually at all. My only concern is that there isn’t a majority miner/instance.
It doesn’t have to be a reddit clone, but the federation needs to move to a more mandatory model, and one that puts the content first. The current system is far too user hostile to allow anything but the lowest common denominator of communities.
Miners are trying to make money, which is why having a faceless and generic flavour/community is irrelevant.
That’s not what motivates folk running lemmy instances
Websites are indistinguishable from each other except for their content.
Federated instances can be like web service providers, only limiting malicious content from users. The magazines/communities are like web sites on a particular host, such as WordPress. They control the content within their scope.
What you are suggesting is that instances should be like AOL, curating the experience. Which is fine if some of them want to do that, but it shouldn’t be the standard.
Websites are indistinguishable from each other except for their content.
Newspapers are indistinguishable from each other except for their content.
Books are indistinguishable from each other except for their content.
Movies are indistinguishable from each other except for their content.
Yep, it’s just as vapid no matter what media you plug in there.
What he’s suggesting is that instances can be like AOL. Not that they have to be. Each instance can present whatever sort of interface to the fediverse that it wants, and people can pick and choose which one they like.
I have zero interest in administrating a generic lemmy instance, including the inevitable hosting of transphobic and bigoted users.
I admin a group focused on the gender diverse community, my community because that’s what’s important to me.
Your solution would lead to less folk volunteering to run communities
How feasible would it be to have levels of federation? Make it possible for instances to partially-federate (if you’re from “your-instan.ce” and its partially-federated with lemmy.world, you don’t see lemmy.world stuff in your feeds, but allow browsing and interacting with “https://your-instan.ce/c/fediverse@lemmy.world”).
Sounds more like a simple filter to your feed. I’m not familiar with the backend side of Lemmy but I would guess it shouldn’t be too hard to implement.
Just save an array of instance domains a user doesn’t want to see in their preferences and filter them out of the post list that gets served to them.
I don’t like seeing something on the internet. PLEASE CHANGE THE INTERNET FOR ME. kthxbai
If this is true, it may also cause users on smaller instances to migrate to bigger instances, because there is more activity. Undermining the power and freedom of the decentralized structure of Lemmy and the fediverse.
