@monerobull @monero @culper Dammit, I liked wizardswap…

@silverpill @monero The existence of a tool like this would be extremely welcome. In my opinion, at least, but I’m sure a lot of other people would find it valuable once they discover it.

@xmr_unlimited I’m not terribly interested in RINO… they’re a third party service, not a piece of software so it doesn’t fit my use case. The fact that I need to register & sign in to even try it out is a big turn off.

What I am curious about, though, is if they’ve refined XMR multisig at all in developing their service, and if so whether they’ve pushed those improvements upstream or not.

@silverpill @monero The integrated chat is part of it, but not the whole.

Multisig is usually pitched as a security or shared custody feature, but a niche I think is underserved here is the use of multisig for trustless escrow between individuals. Haveno’s implementation is integrated too deeply into their exchange platform to be useful independently, and RINO is an enterprise service focused on shared custody, so neither is exactly fit for that purpose.

I talked about Nunchuk in a video last year:

https://peertube.anon-kenkai.com/w/bSyQSapGr7QUaXwiJHUPLV

I went into it in more detail there, but in a nutshell what I like about it is how it incorporates all the necessary tools for trustless escrow in one package. You can generate wallets collaboratively via the integrated chat, discuss the terms, fund the wallet, and disburse funds without needing to fumble between multiple tools.

Since my main focus is providing tools for artists, I can see how such a thing would be very useful for things like commission work. But it can certainly be used for other things too, of course. It’s an otherwise purpose-neutral tool so it’s easy for anybody to just pick it up and use it for whatever purpose they want.

Nunchuk is BTC only, and it can still be useful, but an XMR version would suit my needs even better.

@UncleIroh @Saki RINO claims to use it for their enterprise shared custody service:

https://www.rino.io/

And Haveno is supposed to be using it for escrow:

https://github.com/haveno-dex/haveno/blob/master/docs/trade_protocol/trade-protocol.md

I foolishly assumed this meant it was mature enough to implement more broadly, but I guess not.

@Saki Interesting, thank you. Was the CCS wallet not using multisig the reason for the breach, then? I haven’t followed the incident in detail, I wasn’t sure what allowed the attacker access in the first place.

@silverpill @monero The only user-facing implementations I could find were Haveno (proposed) and RINO (existing), but both are tethered to their respective services, and not useful in a more general sense.

I’m just curious if the lack of GUI implementation has a reason (technical limitations etc), or if it’s just never been attempted. Nunchuk’s design is great for BTC multisig, and an XMR equivalent would be useful.