A Defense Department disagreement over how to bring to justice the accused mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks and two others has thrown the cases into disarray and surfaced tension between the desire of some victims’ families to see a final legal reckoning and the significant obstacles that may make that impossible.
Defense lawyers and some legal experts blame many of the endless delays on what they call the “original sin” haunting the military prosecutions: the illegal torture that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and his co-defendants were subjected to in CIA custody. That years-old abuse has snarled the case, leaving lawyers to hash out legal issues two decades later in the now often-forgotten military courtrooms at the U.S. base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
An approved plea bargain sparing Mohammed and two co-defendants from the death penalty appeared to clear those hurdles and push the cases toward conclusion. But after criticism of the deal from some family members and Republican lawmakers, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin on Aug. 2 revoked the deal signed by the official he had appointed.
Most of the people held are “close enough”. Unfortunately the American people don’t care.
The place should be closed and allow them a public court in the US.
A public court is more likely to let them go free. We can’t convict them in a trial following our laws. Now that is political suicide.
Those terrorists are the third rail. I’m surprised the Dems got this close to a plea deal just because it’s the right thing to do and the only reasonable way out.
Maybe November or December when there’s time for nuance to sink in over soundbites.
Honestly most should be free. I know it is political suicide like making police reform. You don’t want to sound the dog whistle for the racist
You know they orchestrated 9/11, right?
No, we don’t know that. First, not even the military claims that all of the detainies orchestrated 9/11 (which is a much stronger claim then merely being involved).
Second, do we really trust the portion of military that violated domestic law, violated international human rights law, lied to congress about it, and fought for decades against bringing cases to trial?
Is it more likely than not that a given inmate there is a terrorist? Probably. But that is not the standard for indefinite imprisonment.
And Shrub Sr orchestrated the Iraqi war, based on multiple lies told by him and his administration, where over 4500 Americans were killed. Yet I don’t see him in jail for life.
There is a press video about the first drone strike on bin laden life. They believed they killed him with another man. It was two farmers that looked “Muslim.” That was our standard.
Listen to the Pakistani kid talk to congress about how he loves cloudy day bc that is when they know they are safe.
Our history has done countless killings to innocent people. We still haven’t deal with Saudi Arabia which supported 9/11.
We don’t care about justice, we care about money and dog whistles.