More BS for consumers who are now being treated even more like thieves when they shop
A few years ago I remember a solution to problems like this. The store would hire a person and that person would ensure all items a customer had in their cart were scanned. That person would then also help in processing the payment for those items. In exchange for this service the person would collect a wage from the store.
Brilliant! We could call it a… yob?
I’m thinking a rob, because it robs the poor poor shareholders of profits
“Organized retail crime across the entire industry is a serious issue, and has only gotten worse,” said spokesperson Catherine Thomas. She did not provide data to back up the claim.
Riiiight
Is she talking about how Loblaws is essentially an organized crime outfit?
The grocery cartel.
Yes this statement was quite frankly hilarious. I’m certain that the mafia has moved onto stealing bread for black-market redistribution. Or maybe they themselves can no longer afford to shop at Lowblaws.
You know times are tough when even the mafia isn’t recession proof.
“You can trust us to know this,” she went on to say. “We’re the criminals, after all!”
Nah, she’s being truthful. The retail stores have illegally collaborated in secret to raise prices to criminal levels, which is a serious issue.
Customers who go through self-checkout must use the device to scan their receipt’s barcode — confirming that they paid something — which opens a metal gate, letting them leave.
How is that supposed to help at all in stopping theft? “Oh, you paid for something, you definitely aren’t leaving with anything you didn’t pay for.” I can’t see a way “organized crime” could possibly work around that. /s
Its the DRM of shopping.
Impacts legit customers, does very little for everyone else.
After the media hype of a shoplifting crime spree hitting world wide, i imagine this is some businesses answer to that, and they managed to sell it to supermarketsYeah, as much as I think this is a stupid idea I don’t think it’s as bad as Walmart trying to implement Costco style receipt checkers. The less human involvement the more I’m likely to screw up and miss scanning something. Definitely by accident obviously, I wouldn’t want to steal from a faceless corporation that only reluctantly employs anyone.
Small caveat, but Walmart isn’t copying Costco. Sam’s Club has always done the receipt checking, too, and Walmart/Sam’s Club are owned by the same people. So in a way, they’re bringing their Sam’s Club behavior over into general Walmart. What makes this infuriating is not only being treated like a thief and having to go through more steps to get out of the fucking store, but I didn’t pay for any perks or sign any contract that allows you to search my shit.
We don’t have Sam’s club in Canada so I was not aware, but regardless my point was a human looking at what’s in your cart and verifying your receipt vs. a machine checking that a receipt simply exists.
For sure, I wasn’t trying to gotcha or anything. Just adding context for others reading the thread
During the pandemic they forgot to close the store for the entire long weekend and people could just walk in with no employees there at all.
During that time, people grabbed what they needed and left the money at an unattended register.
I’m cynical enough that I suspect these anti-theft measures are an attempt to get people thinking “there must be a lot of theft these days, so the high prices make sense. The government is responsible for crime, not Loblaws”.
I’ve stopped shopping at Loblaw’s as they have make it increasingly clear that they don’t care at all about their customers. I used to actually be a big fan, they had good selection and their house bands were actually pretty good. But I’m tired of continuously being treated like a criminal as they continue to cut costs and raise prices. Their self-checkout stands must be the most user-hostile thing ever. I actually enjoy using self checkouts when they don’t suck. Have you used self-checkout at IKEA? Absolutely pleasurable. You just grab the scanner and go beep-beep-beep and you are done in like 3 seconds. But Loblaw’s is like beep, place item in bagging area, wait for the bagging scale to stabilize, beep, wait for scale, beep, out of space try to put something on the floor, YOU HAVE ANGERED THE SCALE!!! LOCKING WHOLE UNIT UNTIL ATTENDANT COMES!!!, a minute the attendant—who is clearly also tired of these hostile machines—unlocks it without even looking at the error or what you have “stolen”, then I can continue scanning hoping that I don’t anger it again. When I am done it asks how many bags I used, they don’t even have bags anymore. Then it asks if I want to make a charitable donation in their name, go away and donate yourself and I’ll donate on my own. Finally I can pay. And now I have the pleasure being locked in until I scan my receipt.
Also who is this stopping? If I want to steal something I’m not going to sticker-swap or try to sneak it on the scale. I’m just going to leave it in the bag and never scan it. What happens if I didn’t buy anything, am I going to be allowed out? Are they going to demand to pat me down? They don’t have the right to do that.
I’m tired of this shit, I’ve recently been shopping at Farm Boy and they have a nice human who quickly scans my stuff and I am on my way. It isn’t even any more expensive for most things. (though they do frequently lack bulk options which can result in a higher price.) I have the luxury of being able to pretty freely choose where I shop, and I appreciate that no everyone has that privilege, but I’ve started shopping mostly based on how they treat me. Loblaws and Canadian Tire can fuck right off, they treat me like a criminal. Shoppers and Amazon are bad, but not awful. IKEA and Farm Boy treat me like an actual human who’s time and experience is valued, so they get my money.
I don’t know if it’s everywhere, but there’s a Decathlon store near me that has RFID on everything. When you get to the register, you just chuck everything in the box and it shows you what you need to pay. Take something out of the box, and it takes it out of your purchases.
10/10 self-checkout experience.
An old IBM commercial:
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://piped.video/wzFhBGKU6HA?si=NX5vVi6QhSPOOFTS
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I’m open-source; check me out at GitHub.
Same thing at Uniqlo
They can’t legally force you to show a receipt. From recent article on it.
it’s important for consumers to know receipt-checks are not enforceable by law and customers can decline and walk away, said Alex Colangelo, lawyer and business law professor at Humber College. Police officers have the power to arrest … but store security and loss-prevention officers are regular people. They have much more limited powers of arrest under the criminal code,” Colangelo said. “They can ask you to show your receipt and you can consensually allow them to do it. But there is no power or authority to detain you if you say no.”
Detaining someone who has not committed a crime can result in legal issues for retailers, Colangelo said, adding that a customer would “be able to sue for false imprisonment.”
Yeah. Basically they can’t stop you from leaving the store unless they have strong evidence that you committed a crime. Not showing a receipt is not strong evidence. Probably string evidence would be they saw you pick something up and followed you to the door without paying.
Apparently one exception may be Costco because they make you sign an agreement before entering. But I don’t think this has ever been tried in court.
Costco i could see being different because you have a membership, and rules that go with it.
People leave grocery stores without buying anything all the time. The self-checkout area is usually the easiest way to leave because there’s lots of empty space. I don’t see what they can possibly accomplish with this.
I already hated shopping at Superstore. What they accomplished was turning me into a broken glass shopper.
Walmart had stuff like this, so when leaving with nothing bought, i would walk up to the chrome fence and duck and sidestep through it. A Fence with giant holes does nothing to stop somebody who wants to shoplift, it just make life hard for the majority of honest people
I guess it would be easier to leave through it since nobody is watching you leave. That’s probably the idea
My local zehrs setup those one-way gates that everyone just ignores. I’ve never stolen from them and yet I’m treated like a criminal.
Whats criminal is $9 for ground beef.
Whats criminal is $9 for ground beef.
With the amount of effort it takes to raise the cow, and the amount of environmental damage it does, beef only costing $9 per pound is almost criminal.
While true, I think the point here is that Loblaw collects a high margin irrespective of the beef’s cost to make. But yes, the cost of meat has been historically absurdly low. Another example of the market not pricing in externalities.
People buying the premium cuts pay for the cow. Ground beef is the parts they can’t sell as steak or roast or stir fry
It should be cheap
Low fat ground beef should be a little more expensive as trimming the fat before grinding takes skilled time
Customers who go through self-checkout must use the device to scan their receipt’s barcode — confirming that they paid something — which opens a metal gate, letting them leave.
How can scanning a receipt prove that you scanned all the items, and are leaving with only what you paid for?
Also, how does this locking metal gate fall under the municipal fire code?
It is probably wired up to the fire alarm like many emergency exits are. They typically fail-open so that if the wire is cut or the power goes out they can be opened without trouble.
Stupid idea, but probably not a major fire risk.
It is probably wired up to the fire alarm like many emergency exits are.
And if there’s no fire alarm? Maybe an active shooter or other situation that causes a stampede of people to try to leave the store?
Seems like an unnecessary risk to public safety in the name of loss-prevention.
These gates, if they plan to use them, should only lock if a security tag has not been deactivated (triggering an alarm).
The way it seems to be designed is that everyone is guilty of theft until proven they haven’t stolen anything. And it doesn’t seem like scanning the receipt actually proves this.
There is also a good chance that they can be pushed open, just triggering alarm. Based on TFA that is the case.
when leaving the self-checkout area, he didn’t notice the scanner, so he pushed open the exit gate, prompting a loud alarm to go off.
There is also a good chance that they can be pushed open, just triggering alarm.
I hope so. But then it begs the question: will that alarm also be ignored as all other in-store alarms tend to be? LOL
Of course. My argument isn’t that this is a good solution, I don’t think it is. I just don’t think safety is a notable criticism.
Fair point. I don’t know how their metal gates work, so safety came to mind.
edit: corrected Freudian slip.
The article makes it sound like you can push the gate open without a receipt, it will just set off an alarm.
More money wasted on security theater instead of fixing actual issues lol
New York Subway comes to mind.
All of this crap to avoid paying for a few cashiers.
3rd mansions aren’t going to pay for themselves, yo!
At my local Loblaws store they installed stupid metal barriers all around the store entrance and checkout last year. Whereas I previously always returned my cart to the corral at the entrance, that area is now blocked off and it would be annoying to exit.
Now carts, including mine, are just left to pile up randomly near the door until an employee comes around.
Am I the only one who is more annoyed by the lack of efficiency for the consumer. Integrate the checkouts into the exits if you want to do this.
This is common practice here in Germany. All self checkouts I used have a gate requiring the receipt scan. I wasn’t aware that it’s controversial elsewhere. Seems only logical to avoid having personnel monitoring the exit, defeating the purpose of self checkouts.
I remember these from other EU countries as well. Seems reasonable enough.
That’s how it works in Swedish grocery stores
At self checkouts I get it, its annoying but at least makes sense. But there is a Willy’s grocery store near where I live where they do that for the normal cashier checkout too. I forget every time I need to keep my receipt to get out. That’s just bullshit.
“Organized retail crime across the entire industry is a serious issue, and has only gotten worse,” said spokesperson Catherine Thomas. She did not provide data to back up the claim.
Put up or shut up. I hope Catherine Thomas steps on a Lego.
Also everyone should just keep doing what the old people do and go through the gates without scanning.
I won’t scan shit. They have the damn receipt already. Read that.
I guess they’re trying to protect themselves from me pulling random receipt from the 200 that live in my wallet I’ll never do anything with.
